Man United vs Man City: Derby History, Stats & Watch Guide

Ask any football fan in Manchester about the other half of the city and you’ll get an earful — the kind that spills into songs, pub arguments, and occasional pitch invasions. The Manchester Derby isn’t just a matchup; it’s a fault line in English football that stretches back to 1881, when a team called Newton Heath first beat St Mark’s 3-0. Decades later, United still lead the all-time head-to-head by 81 wins to City’s 63, yet Pep Guardiola’s side has won nine of the last 15 derbies.

Total matches played: 198 · Man Utd wins: 81 · Man City wins: 63 · Draws: 54 · Recent result (Apr 2025): 0-0

Who is better, Man Utd or Man City?

The short answer depends on which decade you’re measuring. United have won 81 of 198 meetings across all competitions, a lead they built during decades of dominance from the Busby Babes through the Ferguson era. City, however, have flipped the script since Pep Guardiola arrived in 2016.

Head-to-head record

Across 198 official derbies, Manchester United hold a 81-63 advantage with 54 draws. But the picture shifts when you zoom into recent history. City won nine of the last 15 Premier League meetings, scoring 29 goals in the process. At the Etihad specifically, City have won four of their last five home derbies by a combined aggregate of 17-7 (Sports Mole). The all-time record is United’s, but the momentum belongs to City.

Recent form

City took the Community Shield 7-6 on penalties after a 1-1 draw on 10 August 2024. United responded by winning 2-1 at the Etihad in December 2024 under Ruben Amorim — one of the standout results of his early tenure. The April 2025 return at Old Trafford ended 0-0, suggesting the gap may be narrowing (Sports Mole). Wayne Rooney remains the all-time derby scorer with 11 goals for United, while Francis Lee and Joe Hayes share City’s record at 10 each.

Trophies comparison

United’s trophy cabinet still dwarfs City’s in total major honors, though City have closed the gap significantly since their 2011-12 Premier League title. The balance sheet now reads differently than it did 30 years ago — City have four Premier Leagues since 2012, while United have three since 1992.

The next few seasons under new managerial eras on both sides will determine whether this trajectory holds.

Who is the bigger club, Manchester City or Manchester United?

“Bigger” is a loaded word — it can mean historical success, global reach, revenue, or cultural weight. The evidence splits depending on which metric you prioritize.

Historical success

By total trophy haul, United remain ahead. Sir Alex Ferguson’s 13 Premier League titles and two Champions League trophies anchor a legacy City are still building toward. City’s recent dominance (four PL titles since 2018, plus the treble in 2023) has narrowed the gap but not closed it.

Global fanbase

This is where things get nuanced. YouGov data from their 8,551-fan survey found that United’s fanbase skews younger and more globally distributed, with particular strength in the 18-34 age group. City fans, by contrast, are older on average and more geographically concentrated around Manchester (YouGov). The global brand advantage belongs to United; the local cultural root belongs to City.

Stadium and revenue

Old Trafford (capacity 74,879) historically dwarfed the Etihad (53,000), but City’s stadium expansion plans and surrounding development have closed that gap. On revenue, United’s commercial machine still leads in absolute terms, though City’s Emirati ownership has made them Financial Fair Play regulars in recent transfer windows.

The rivalry cuts both ways: United win on historical weight and global scale; City win on recent dominance and local identity.

Who has more fans, Man U or Man City?

The numbers tell a complicated story. United claim the larger global following; City claim the more concentrated local one.

UK fandom data

YouGov’s fan survey of 8,551 supporters found that 49% of Man City fans are based in North West England, compared to just 28% of Man United fans. The data confirms City fans are far more geographically concentrated around Manchester, while United fans are spread more evenly across the UK and beyond (YouGov).

Global support

United’s global brand, amplified by decades of commercial deals, gives them the larger international footprint. City, despite heavy investment in global scouting and overseas friendlies, remain more niche outside Manchester. The 18-34 demographic skews heavily toward United globally — a function of sustained Premier League exposure since the 1990s.

Social media metrics

United’s official channels consistently outperform City’s across Instagram, Twitter/X, and TikTok. The gap is partly historical (United were a global brand before social media existed) and partly cultural (their trophy drought since 2017 has paradoxically kept them in the news.

City fans in Manchester are a tight, locally-rooted community; United fans globally are a sprawling, younger diaspora.

Is the Manchester Derby on TV?

Premier League derbies are almost always broadcast, though exact channel assignments and kick-off times vary by season and country.

Broadcast options

In the UK, Sky Sports and TNT Sports share Premier League rights. Derby matches typically appear on Sky Sports Main Event or TNT Sports 1. Amazon Prime Video also occasionally broadcasts midweek rounds. In the US, NBCUniversal holds rights and streams matches on Peacock and NBC stations. International viewers should check regional rights holders (Flashscore).

Live streaming

All UK streaming options require subscriptions — there is no free-to-air broadcast for Premier League derbies. Key exceptions include the FA Cup, where BBC and ITV sometimes show matches free-to-air. The Women’s Super League derbies are broadcast on BBC iPlayer and the FA Player.

International viewing

DAZN holds rights in Spain, Canada, and several other markets. beIN SPORTS covers the Middle East and North Africa. Fans outside these regions should verify with their local broadcaster. Specific upcoming fixture dates and channel assignments are typically confirmed 2-4 weeks before each match.

No single source confirms all upcoming derby broadcast details for every market. Viewers should verify with club websites and league schedules closer to each fixture.

Why does Manchester have two teams?

Two teams in one city isn’t unique to Manchester — London has more than a dozen — but the Manchester pairing has become one of English football’s defining rivalries. Here’s how it happened.

Club origins

Manchester United began as Newton Heath LYR Football Club in 1878, founded by railway workers at the Carriage and Wagon department of the Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway. Manchester City, originally St Mark’s (West Gorton), was formed in 1880 as a church team. The two clubs diverged early: Newton Heath went professional in 1889 and eventually became United in 1902; City turned professional in 1894. Their first meeting came in 1881, with Newton Heath winning 3-0 (Sports Mole).

Rivalry history

The rivalry deepened through the 20th century as United became England’s dominant club under Matt Busby and later Sir Alex Ferguson, while City oscillated between tiers. The modern edge came when City’s Abu Dhabi ownership transformed them into a top-tier club from 2008 onward. YouGov data shows that 9 out of 10 top “pet hates” among City fans are United-related, while United fans cite Liverpool and Arsenal higher on their rival lists — suggesting the imbalance in mutual intensity (YouGov).

Key matches

The derby’s most memorable encounters include City’s 5-1 win at Old Trafford in 2011, United’s 8-2 victory in 2011, and the 6-3 thriller at the Etihad in the 2022-23 season — the highest-scoring derby on record. The 2019 2-1 City win that effectively clinched the 2018-19 title is another landmark.

Newton Heath’s railway origins versus St Mark’s church roots set the template for 145 years of parallel development, each pulling from different veins of Manchester’s footballing identity.

How to Watch the Derby: Step by Step

Three steps to catch the next Manchester Derby live, whether you’re in the UK or abroad.

1. Check the schedule: Premier League fixtures are released in June for the full season. Derby dates are typically clustered in December-January and April-May windows.
2. Identify your broadcaster: In the UK, Sky Sports or TNT Sports will carry most PL derbies. FA Cup meetings may appear on BBC or ITV (free-to-air). Women’s derbies stream on BBC iPlayer.
3. Subscribe or access: UK viewers need Sky Sports/TNT Sports accounts or a NOW TV/Discovery+ pass. International viewers should check DAZN, beIN SPORTS, or their regional rights holder.

Comparison Table: Man Utd vs Man City

Three metrics, two clubs, one snapshot of where the rivalry stands.

United’s historical advantage remains substantial, but City’s recent dominance in head-to-head encounters signals a shift in competitive fortunes.

Related reading: transfer window dates · Ross County FC fixtures

The fierce Manchester Derby’s balance often shifts, as their comprehensive head-to-head record illustrates with historical wins and standout recent clashes.

Frequently asked questions